8/22/2026 at 5:03:09 PM
I do like the embrace of The Office as a theme because it so accurately represents the dysfunction of all of the agent swarms I’ve seen: Different personalities pursuing their own little goals that are all competing with each other in subtle ways that eventually leads a funny collapse of the outcome you wanted.There’s no denying that LLMs are getting better by the month, but the current wave of LLM office and personal assistants reminds me of the old trend where people were hiring personal virtual assistants from foreign countries to manage their work and interface with people. It seemed like an obvious time saver but every time I interacted with someone’s virtual assistant it felt like I was playing a little game of navigating hidden structures and communication barriers to get the message I needed to the person hiding behind it all. Then there were the inevitable scheduling failings, missed meetings, dropped emails, and other things that get blamed on the assistant. I’m getting deja vu watching it all happen again with LLMs replacing virtual assistants and outsourced teams.
Maybe these concepts work for people who are trying to solo dev and who find it interesting to set up and debug little systems for everything they do, but I really don’t like working with anyone who surrounds themselves with one of these multi-agent coordination systems as an external shell. Keep it to the internal work and maybe it’s fun for some people.
by Aurornis
8/22/2026 at 8:00:08 PM
In areas of applicability where GenAI to now considered to be good/great, the pattern I've observed is a frighteningly rapid progression from "abjectly terrible", to "middling and mostly more trouble than it's worth" and then "good/great".Agentic coding and image generation are probably the best examples of this.
There's no guarantee that this trend will be seen with virtual assistants, but if it does, we're on the brink of incredible. Dedicated personal assistants, that actually know and understand one's context and work well together, are unarguably hugely appreciated by those who can afford them.
by mrshadowgoose
8/23/2026 at 2:08:42 AM
Nothing can go wrong if we reduce direct human interaction even further and pay some megacorporations to MITM all of it.by ShinyLeftPad
8/23/2026 at 10:50:22 AM
All mediated by the Meta-Human Facebook and Instagram that these people want to shit into the world.I dream of a world where I never know if anything is real, or if the person I'm talking to is even human.
by podgietaru
8/24/2026 at 2:27:24 AM
But imagine how targeted the ads will be!by ShinyLeftPad
8/23/2026 at 4:33:54 AM
That future does not sound fun, let alone incredible.by Forgeties79
8/23/2026 at 10:15:35 AM
Am I the only one who doesn't want a virtual assistant? I just struggle to understand this goal we apparently are all aiming forI want to be an active player in my own life. I want to do things even if there's some friction.
All I can imagine is that future from WallE where everything is so easy no one tries or does anything at all
by over_bridge
8/23/2026 at 2:28:23 PM
Can’t say you’re the only one but I certainly want an assistant.I’ve been putting off some dental work for a year or more because I have an implant that’s come lose, and the two dentists I saw about it said they’d have to remove the crown, send pictures to some lab that might be able to identify the manufacturer (or maybe not), maybe get the right tooling, maybe have to replace the entire thing (thousands of dollars, removing and resetting a post in my jaw), etc etc. all because I didn’t know the manufacturer of an implant I got 20 years ago.
Claude cowork was able to understand the problem, interview me, find dental insurance paperwork in my email, identify the prosthedontist used, find that that office had closed years ago, find where the practitioner moved to, their new practice, and get me a number to call.
Within a couple of ours I had the manufacturer, procedure notes, and X-rays from the installation.
Is that WALL-E style laziness? Maybe. But I’m good with it, as I have line of sight to solving an annoying problem that seemed insurmountable.
by brookst
8/23/2026 at 10:51:42 AM
I'm just not that annoyed by having to search for a flight, or train, or bus. Or make plans. Or find a restaurant. I'm not annoyed enough by these trivial tasks to want to outsource them.I don't want to ask Siri to book me a restaurant, when the alternative is a quick google search.
by podgietaru
8/23/2026 at 2:06:57 PM
It's helps to remember that most of the folks pushing this are ambitious but fundamentally lazy.by flkiwi
8/23/2026 at 2:30:41 PM
What an odd claim.Is it possible they have families, aging relatives to care for, health issues or other reasons that time is precious and “spend an hour correlating amazing restaurants with their available bookings against my crazy schedule” is not a good solution?
IMO the greatest failure of the HN-style tech community is complete lack of empathy, or even awareness, for people whose lives have different shapes.
by brookst
8/23/2026 at 4:47:19 PM
frankly, this is just a lazy and ignorant povby kthinckley