alt.hn

3/28/2025 at 2:44:59 PM

Show HN: Cursor IDE now remembers your coding prefs using MCP

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 3:49:27 PM

What's the advantage over the built-in solution? (and before it, .cursorrules)

https://docs.cursor.com/context/rules-for-ai

by jasonjmcghee

3/28/2025 at 4:35:01 PM

You add some additional instructions to the Cursor rules here: https://github.com/getzep/graphiti/tree/main/mcp_server#inte...

I think the difference is that Cursor doesn't update its rules automatically as you work, while this might?

by striking

3/28/2025 at 9:26:24 PM

.cursorrules and other files that are added as system instructions in Cursor are just files, meaning the agent can edit them easely - you can tell it from the chat to add something to a rule and it will do it.

You are also wrong that it cannot do this automatically: if you add to the system instruction to record all important decisions in .cursorrules, it will record them there. automatically

by dan_voronov

3/28/2025 at 4:48:21 PM

Correct. The Graphiti MCP server, with the help of the agent, stores and retrieves preferences and requirements automatically without requiring rule changes.

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 8:03:30 PM

is this cursor specific or can i integrate with other things if im insane?

by randall

3/28/2025 at 9:24:52 PM

But you could tell cursor to update its rules automatically, no?

by rahimnathwani

3/28/2025 at 5:55:14 PM

The over engineering here is commendable for something that provides most likely marginal value whilst still needing more api calls to summarize everything you do.

by bfeynman

3/28/2025 at 9:07:44 PM

You've described my job for the last few years.

by pizzafeelsright

3/29/2025 at 2:06:13 AM

You're not kind, but you're not wrong.

by knowsuchagency

3/28/2025 at 8:39:11 PM

Come on. You don’t need to be a bully. This person worked hard on their thing.

by zachlatta

3/29/2025 at 10:08:02 AM

It's a matter of perspective.

by yard2010

3/28/2025 at 10:08:45 PM

We built Graphiti's MCP server for many different use cases. It's a great enhancement to Cursor, but may not offer significant value for your use case. No offense taken.

by roseway4

3/29/2025 at 10:07:26 AM

I've been looking for a thing like this in the last few weeks to add memory to my bot. Initially I started implementing a poor man solution, realizing how hard the problem is. Thank you for creating this! This is awesome. Best of luck monetizing this!

by yard2010

3/30/2025 at 12:31:14 AM

Thank you! Zep, our commercial memory service, utilized Graphiti as it's internal memory store.

by roseway4

3/29/2025 at 1:14:37 AM

The concept is promising, but I tested it and found the performance quite poor. I used one of my Python projects for the test, which consists of about 10k lines of Python code. The model I utilized was Claude 3.7 Sonnet with thinking.

in the first conversation round, I asked Claude to grasp the overall project and initialize its memory. Unfortunately, Claude experienced a hallucination and generated an episode that included a full name entirely unrelated to my project's actual full name, as my project name is an abbreviation.

In the second conversation round, I provided Claude with the full name of my project and requested it to correct its memory. In response, Claude apologized and claimed that it now understood the full name of my project, but it did not utilize any MCP command.

In the third conversation round, I specifically asked it to use the MCP command to update its memory. Claude successfully added a new episode but failed to remove the incorrect old episode.

It wasn't until the fourth conversation round that I directly pointed out that it should eliminate the incorrect old episode, and Claude finally completed the memory initialization that should have been accomplished at the end of the first round.

I have set up the correct Cursor Rules according to the README.

At this point, it appears this project is challenging to use with natural language. I need to explicitly instruct Claude on which specific tools to call for various operations to achieve the intended outcome.

Am I doing something wrong?

by ekaesmem

3/30/2025 at 12:26:14 AM

I used Claude 3.7 Sonnet for the Cursor Agent when building the demo. Happy to hop on a call to walk through your experience, as I'm surprised the agent performed so poorly. daniel AT getzep.com

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 4:33:23 PM

This looks interesting but somewhat complicated or not obvious how to get going in a classic "Show HN" style.

The requirement for an OpenAI key may also be a little off-putting, or at least, could do with some indication of realistic costs; most Cursor users will likely need a significant motivation to add to the subscription they already have.

Don't get me wrong, this could be a really worthwhile addition to the LLM coding toolset but I think it needs some work on the presentation as to how to get quickly up and running.

by mellosouls

3/28/2025 at 4:51:09 PM

Graphiti uses OpenAI (or other LLMs) to build the knowledge graph. Setting up the MCP server is fairly straight forward: https://github.com/getzep/graphiti/tree/main/mcp_server

There's also a Docker Compose setup: https://github.com/getzep/graphiti/tree/main/mcp_server#runn...

The Cursor MCP setup is also simple:

```{ "mcpServers": { "Graphiti": { "url": "http://localhost:8000/sse" } } }```

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 5:05:08 PM

How complex is the system? Can a local model or the agent itself be used instead?

by jasonjmcghee

3/28/2025 at 5:02:38 PM

not obvious to me why this is an improvement of having the agent just update the rule files directly itself; i have it do that to my various AI-targeted readme files and it works great.

by octernion

3/28/2025 at 5:28:54 PM

Graphiti MCP can recall more than just preferences and coding styles. Application specifications and evolution of these may be stored. For any non-trivial application, config files would likely be a misfit for this use ase.

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 7:38:13 PM

i store those in my rules files - really all the knowledge i would pass onto another engineer (incl. AI). not sure i follow why you would avoid putting that into AI-readable files in your repo like i do now.

by octernion

3/28/2025 at 5:41:51 PM

One of the big problems I have with cursor is that it ignores the rules frequently. For example, working in the front-end it will sometimes totally ignore all the components that I have explicitly told it to use. Would this... fix that?

by bbertelsen

3/28/2025 at 5:54:14 PM

This would help, but you can also use a more aggressive approach to cursor rules: https://ghuntley.com/stdlib/

Using file pattern matching and automatic attachment makes it much, much more sticky in my experience.

by eightysixfour

3/28/2025 at 6:45:48 PM

I actually had Claude Desktop with the file system MCP write me out a pretty nice suite of rules directly in the .cursor/rules folder.

by kelleyperry

3/29/2025 at 8:19:18 AM

I don’t see how this is palatable by serious organizations? So you build this huge memory graph of preferences? But none of it is explicit? It’s all just magic? The attack vectors from a security angle seem insane. Also the absence of any explicitness in how you define standards seems completely not viable in a commercial context? I mean it’s crazy cool as a hobby project, but also seems not to have a serious commercial viability?

by loujaybee

3/30/2025 at 12:28:02 AM

There are definitely potential security issues with memory for coding agents, which apply to not only Cursor but also Windsurf. Looking forward to more research in this area.

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 3:49:57 PM

This is exciting!

Glancing through the article, I can't tell, is this Cursor specific? Some of us are raw dogging VS Code with https://cline.bot, which supports MCP servers: https://cline.bot/mcp-marketplace.

Would love to try this out in Cline!

by adenta

3/28/2025 at 5:00:13 PM

The MCP server will work with any MCP client.

by roseway4

3/28/2025 at 4:56:59 PM

Looks super interesting. I hadn't heard of Graphiti before, but the idea of giving Cursor some kind of persistent, structured memory across sessions definitely sounds useful.

by stosssik

3/28/2025 at 7:36:06 PM

It's there some way to control what gets updated in the database and how and when?

For example I'd like to be in control of the archtectural patterns and not let the LLM drive this.

by Garlef

3/28/2025 at 7:45:59 PM

Oh I see: I could define my own entities similar to what your did for your integration and then let the agents interact with them through the MCP?

For example ("architecture pattern" - auch as the dependency rule from clean architecture, "development areas" such as frontend, backend)

by Garlef

3/28/2025 at 8:02:54 PM

sweet!!

by randall

3/28/2025 at 3:52:27 PM

This is so exciting!!!

by zman0225

3/28/2025 at 5:00:23 PM

Thank you!

by roseway4